Peer-to-peer Optimization in Large Unreliable Networks with Branch-and-Bound and Particle Swarms

Abstract. Recent developments in the area of peer-to-peer (P2P) computing have enabled a new generation of fully-distributed global optimization algorithms via providing self-organizing control and load balancing mechanisms in very large scale, unreliable networks. Such decentralized networks (lacking a GRID-style resource management and scheduling infrastructure) are an increasingly important platform to exploit. So far, little is known about the scaling and reliability of optimization algorithms in P2P environments. In this paper we present empirical results comparing two algorithms for real-valued search spaces in large-scale and unreliable networks. Some interesting, and perhaps counter-intuitive findings are presented: for example, failures in the network can in fact significantly improve performance under some conditions. The two algorithms that are compared are a known distributed particle swarm optimization (PSO) algorithm and a novel P2P branch-and-bound (B&B) algorithm based on interval arithmetic. Although our B&B algorithm is not a black-box heuristic, the PSO algorithm is competitive in certain cases, in particular, in larger networks. Comparing two rather different paradigms for solving the same problem gives a better characterization of the limits and possibilities of optimization in P2P networks.