The present work aims to investigate the effects of the execution of the European Court of Human Rights’ (ECtHR) judgments on the Italian criminal res judicata. In the absence of a specific legislation, the research purpose is to face the numerous jurisprudential guidelines recently emerged on the above-mentioned topic by using a systematic approach, that can guide the study of a magmatic and evolving matter. The perspective adopted is a strict interpretation of the criminal res judicata institution, in response to the idea of a progressive erosion of its traditional features of stability and immutability. Multiple lenses can be adopted to analyse the research theme: it can be studied both from the point of view of criminal law (substantive and procedural) and of constitutional law. The present work focuses on criminal procedure law aspects of the matter. The goal of the first chapter - a sort of introduction - is twofold. On the one hand, the chapter is intended to present the domestic obligation to implement the ECtHR’s judgments in criminal cases. On the other, this chapter provides an analysis of the res judicata institution in the Italian procedural criminal law system. The second and third chapters represent the core of this work. In order to comply with the above mentioned international obligation (both in the individual cases decided by the ECtHR and in the other cases similar to those already judged by the Court), the domestic judges in several cases have adopted procedural legal remedies, provided for other purposes by the Italian legislator. Such an analogical use of existing domestic remedies should be looked at critically. Seeking to establish a comparison with the French and German legal systems, the last chapter depicts the pars costruens of the Doctoral Thesis.
Giudicato penale ed esecuzione delle sentenze della Corte europea dei diritti dell'uomo: profili processuali / Bigiarini, Andrea. - (2020 Mar 10), pp. 1-199.
|Titolo:||Giudicato penale ed esecuzione delle sentenze della Corte europea dei diritti dell'uomo: profili processuali|
|Anno di pubblicazione:||2020-03-10|
|Struttura:||Facoltà di Giurisprudenza|
|Corso di dottorato:||Comparative and European Legal Studies|
|Relatore:||Di Paolo, Gabriella|
|Tutor esterno:||Conti, Carlotta|
|Tesi in cotutela:||no|
|Digital Object Identifier (DOI):||10.15168/11572_253368|
|Appare nelle tipologie:||08.1 Tesi di dottorato (Doctoral Thesis)|